If we are not discerning, one person’s bad theology is another person’s favorite doctrine. I try to use biblical concepts to form my theological concepts. I am not infallible. I make mistakes and learn more as I go. I hope my theology is progressing toward purer truth all the time.
A persistent saying in Christian circles is “Everything happens for a reason.” This has the ring of faith and of yielding to the mysterious will of God. But I think it is bad theology in the way most people view it.
I have heard this from people who have experienced great tragedy, or by those who are trying to console victims of life’s horrors. The unstated logic of the statement goes something like this:
- God is in control of all things, therefore of everything that happens.
- God has a plan for all things and this plan is continually unfolding according to his will.
- Therefore, when bad things happen, God is the ultimate cause.
- When we suffer tragedy, saying “Everything happens for a reason” is a polite way to blame God.
- Our hope is that God’s reasons will favor us in the future.
I just don’t think it works this way or that the Bible teaches this. I will admit there are places where the Bible authors seem to attribute life’s good things and life’s terrible things to God. Perhaps most famous are the words of Job:
Shall we accept good from God, and not trouble? (Job 2:10)
Not all tragedies have a simple, easily explained cause. But many do. Many are the result of sinful behavior, especially injustice at the hands of greedy and unprincipled individuals. Sin causes pain for us and for others. Yet the Bible does not teach us to passively accept injustice. We are to fight it, to champion justice.
In the end, God’s control of his creation is not in question. He can bring good from catastrophe. But this does not mean he brings catastrophe to cause good. So let’s replace “Everything happens for a reason” with “God’s love is from everlasting to everlasting.”
Nebraska Christian College of Hope International University